The Australian Securities and Investments Commission recently issued its Oversight of financial reporting and audit 2025–26
Much of the content echoes issues which have come up in Canada in the past – in some cases they’ve been around for years – but that only confirms the eternal challenges and forces that might lead a practitioner or an auditor to slip up, overly rationalize or cut corners in those areas. Compared to similar reports from Canada and ESMA and elsewhere, the report draws considerable colour from its use of specific issuer and auditor names. A selection of financial reporting issues (retaining the report’s references to local nomenclature):
- Viva Energy Group Limited incorrectly determined the level at which to test its convenience retail sites for impairment. Some retail sites were assessed for impairment as part of the Shell Card cash generating unit (CGU), on the basis that the Shell Card is a wholesale offering across the company’s Australia-wide network, rather than being assessed as individual sites. This approach was considered inconsistent with the requirements of AASB 136 as the recoverable amount of each retail site in the Shell Card CGU could be determined on an individual site basis. Subsequent to our inquiries, the company recognized a total impairment expense of $558.8 million for its retail convenience sites. Of this total, $25 million was attributable to the change in approach…
- Mobile Asset Holdings Ltd had measured its Platform Assets at fair value despite the absence of an active market, resulting in the valuation model lacking sufficient observable data. Subsequent to our inquiries, starting from its next financial report, the company will no longer value its Platform Assets at fair value and instead implement the cost model under Australian Accounting Standard AASB 138 Intangible assets.
- Pearl Corporation of Australia Pty. Ltd. recognized and valued its biological assets at lower of cost and net realizable value under Australian Accounting Standard AASB 102 Inventories, instead of fair value under Australian Accounting Standard AASB 141 Agriculture. Subsequent to our inquiries, in its next financial report, the company will reclassify and measure its biological assets under AASB 141.
- We contacted Pure Foods Tasmania Limited about the recoverability of their deferred tax assets, given they had recorded losses for the past five years. Following our surveillance, the company reduced the amount of deferred tax assets recognized in its interim financial report.
- We contacted Safecorp Group Ltd about their compliance with Australian Accounting Standard AASB 119 Employee benefits, and the measurement of their employee benefits provisions. The company had not included on-costs, such as superannuation, WorkCover and payroll tax when calculating the value of their provisions for annual leave, rostered days off and long service leave. Instead, it recognised these on-costs as expenses when the related employee benefits were taken or paid to employees. Following our surveillance, in its next financial report, the company agreed to include on-costs when calculating its employee benefits provisions.
In Australia, ASIC is the statutory regulator with the power to perform audit surveillance. The review draws on nineteen such surveillances during the year, yielding a diverse mix of findings (actions taken during the year include commencing Federal Court proceedings against three auditors and two related authorized audit companies, alleging serious audit failures). The area of revenue alone yields the following items:
- one auditor from BDO did not: –
- verify amounts invoiced to approved pricing documentation to conclude on the accuracy of transaction prices allocated to performance obligations, and
- adequately test the accuracy of deferred revenue model inputs by relying on substantive testing performed for only a subset of the population
- one auditor from Deloitte did not test a sufficient number of samples for the trade receivables balances
- one auditor from Ernst & Young did not adequately test revenue controls, including segregation of preparer and reviewer roles
- one auditor from PwC did not:
- adequately consider the significance of account balances when determining material business components, and
- consider testing significant transactions outside the ordinary course of business when performing journal entry testing one auditor from a small audit firm did not design and execute appropriate substantive analytical procedures, and
- one auditor from a small audit firm did not obtain sufficient appropriate audit evidence over the occurrence and accuracy of revenue and receivables.
Other areas covered include impairment (one auditor from Deloitte failed to adequately evaluate the reasonableness of key assumptions used in impairment models, including the appropriateness of the company-specific risk premium in the discount rates and the application of terminal value calculations, and assess the competence, capability and objectivity of a management expert), investments (one auditor from Ernst & Young failed to sufficiently evaluate the work of the component auditor’s audit expert, including the reasonableness and supportability of key assumptions and calculations used in investment valuations), and many observations regarding the quality of audit documentation. All good stuff!
The opinions expressed are solely those of the author.